If you have a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policy in California, you have a right that people in most other states don’t: each year, around your birthday, you can switch to another supplement without answering health questions. It’s called the California birthday rule, and it can help you keep your coverage in line with your budget as premiums change over time.
Here’s how it works, who it helps, and what to watch out for.
Why health questions matter for Medigap
When you first get Medicare Part B at 65 or older, you have a six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period. During that window, an insurer can’t turn you down or charge you more because of your health.
After that window ends, in most states, insurance companies can ask health questions (called medical underwriting) when you apply for a new supplement. If you’ve had a heart condition, cancer or another serious diagnosis, you could be denied or charged more. Many people end up feeling “stuck” in a policy whose premium keeps rising.
California’s birthday rule addresses that problem.
How the California birthday rule works
Under California Insurance Code §10192.11(h), if you already have a Medicare Supplement policy, you have a window of at least 60 days that begins on your birthday each year. During that window:
- You can switch to a new Medigap policy with equal or lesser benefits than the one you have now.
- You can switch to any insurance company that sells that plan in California. You aren’t limited to your current insurer.
- The new insurer can’t deny you coverage or base the price on your health, or condition the policy’s issuance or effectiveness on your medical condition.
The window opens every year, so you don’t have to use it this year to keep the right for next year.
What “equal or lesser benefits” means
Medigap plans are standardized by letter. A Plan G from one company covers the same benefits as a Plan G from another company. Premiums and the company’s service can differ; compare the policy details before switching.
Under the birthday rule, you could, for example:
- Move from Plan G to Plan G with a different company
- Move from Plan G to Plan N, which has fewer benefits
- Move from Plan F to Plan G or Plan N (Plan F itself is only available to people who were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020)
You generally could not use the birthday rule to move from Plan N up to Plan G, because Plan G has more benefits.
Hypothetical examples
Example 1: Comparing the same plan. Linda in Carlsbad turns 72 on May 10. She has Plan G, and her premium went up again this year. Between May 10 and early July, she can apply for Plan G with any company selling it in California, without health questions. The standardized benefits stay the same; she should compare premiums, service and policy details before choosing.
Example 2: Trading some coverage for savings. Robert in Escondido has Plan G and was recently diagnosed with a heart condition. He’d like a lower monthly premium and is comfortable paying small copays. During his birthday window, he can move to Plan N, and the new insurer can’t use his heart condition to deny or condition coverage or charge him more.
Example 3: Timing. Maria’s birthday is October 3. She should start comparing options in September so a new policy can be in place within her window, and she should keep her old policy until the new one is active.
Who the birthday rule helps
- People whose supplement premiums have risen. Rates often go up with age and over time. The birthday rule lets you shop each year.
- People with health conditions. Without the rule, they might not pass underwriting.
- Retirees on a fixed budget. Moving to a plan with fewer benefits can lower monthly costs. Your financial advisor can help you weigh premium savings against possible out-of-pocket costs.
The birthday rule does not help people with Medicare Advantage switch into a supplement. It applies only if you already have a Medigap policy. If you’re trying to decide between the two kinds of coverage, read our guide to Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement.
Is there an anniversary rule in California?
Some states have an “anniversary rule” tied to the date your policy started. California’s annual switching right is tied to your birthday, not your policy anniversary. Some insurers may offer their own policies or switching options, but those are company rules, not a state guarantee. Ask before you assume.
Tips before you switch
- Compare total cost, not just this year’s premium. Ask how each company has raised rates over time.
- Don’t cancel your old policy first. Wait until the new policy is approved and has a start date, then cancel to avoid a gap.
- Watch the calendar. If you miss the window, you may need health questions or another enrollment right to switch before your next birthday window.
- Remember Part D is separate. Your Medigap policy doesn’t include drug coverage. Your Part D plan isn’t affected by the switch.
- Get help. A licensed broker can compare available supplements side by side at no cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long is the California Medigap birthday rule window?
At least 60 days, beginning on your birthday each year. Confirm your application deadline and effective date with the insurer.
Can I switch to a different insurance company under the birthday rule?
Yes. You can move to any company that offers the plan you’re choosing in California, as long as the new plan has equal or lesser benefits.
Can I upgrade my plan using the birthday rule?
No. The rule covers moving to a plan with equal or lesser benefits. Moving to a plan with more benefits may require health questions.
Does the birthday rule apply if I have Medicare Advantage?
No. It applies to people who already have a Medicare Supplement policy. Other rules, such as certain guaranteed-issue rights, may apply when leaving Medicare Advantage.
Will my premium go up if I switch?
Premiums depend on the company, the plan, your age and where you live. Switching can lower your premium, but it isn’t guaranteed. Compare quotes before you decide.
Get Help With Your Birthday Window
We help Medicare Supplement holders across North County, including Carlsbad, Escondido, Oceanside, Encinitas, San Marcos, Vista and Poway, compare their options each year. Book a call with Brian McArthur or call (619) 374-0096 a few weeks before your birthday.

[…] Timing matters here too. Your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period starts when you’re 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During that window, you can buy a supplement without health questions. In California, people who already have a supplement may also benefit from the Medigap birthday rule. […]
[…] For more on how we work alongside advisors, see Working with your financial advisor on Medicare. If you’re just getting started, our Turning 65 in North County San Diego checklist covers enrollment timing. IRMAA applies whether you choose a Medicare Supplement or Medicare Advantage; our guide to Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement walks through that choice, and if you already have a supplement, read about California’s Medigap birthday rule. […]
[…] After this window closes, you may have to answer health questions to buy a supplement. California does have a birthday rule that helps people who already have a supplement switch later. See our article on California’s Medigap birthday rule. […]